Baseball Magazine All-Star
1520 award winners
Award Overview
- Award Name
- Baseball Magazine All-Star
- Total Winners
- 1520
- First Awarded
- 1908
- Most Recent
- 1950
All Winners
Complete list of Baseball Magazine All-Star recipients
| Year | Player Name | Team | League |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1950 | Joe DiMaggio | NYY | AL |
| 1950 | Joe DiMaggio | NYY | ML |
| 1950 | Ted Williams | BOS | AL |
| 1950 | Stan Musial | STL | NL |
| 1950 | Stan Musial | STL | ML |
| 1950 | Bobby Doerr | BOS | ML |
| 1950 | Bobby Doerr | BOS | AL |
| 1950 | Bob Elliott | BSN | NL |
| 1950 | George Kell | DET | AL |
| 1950 | George Kell | DET | ML |
| 1950 | Yogi Berra | NYY | AL |
| 1950 | Yogi Berra | NYY | ML |
| 1950 | Ralph Kiner | PIT | ML |
| 1950 | Ralph Kiner | PIT | NL |
| 1950 | Jackie Robinson | BRO | NL |
| 1950 | Warren Spahn | BSN | ML |
| 1950 | Warren Spahn | BSN | NL |
| 1950 | Bob Lemon | CLE | AL |
| 1950 | Vic Raschi | NYY | AL |
| 1950 | Vic Raschi | NYY | ML |
| 1950 | Roy Campanella | BRO | NL |
| 1950 | Phil Rizzuto | NYY | ML |
| 1950 | Phil Rizzuto | NYY | AL |
| 1950 | Vic Wertz | DET | AL |
| 1950 | Walt Dropo | BOS | AL |
| 1950 | Carl Furillo | BRO | NL |
| 1950 | Carl Furillo | BRO | ML |
| 1950 | Granny Hamner | PHI | NL |
| 1950 | Art Houtteman | DET | AL |
| 1950 | Larry Jansen | NY1 | NL |
| 1950 | Jim Konstanty | PHI | ML |
| 1950 | Jim Konstanty | PHI | NL |
| 1950 | Duke Snider | BRO | NL |
| 1949 | Ted Williams | BOS | AL |
| 1949 | Ted Williams | BOS | ML |
| 1949 | Enos Slaughter | STL | NL |
| 1949 | Vern Stephens | BOS | AL |
| 1949 | Vern Stephens | BOS | ML |
| 1949 | Stan Musial | STL | ML |
| 1949 | Stan Musial | STL | NL |
| 1949 | Dom DiMaggio | BOS | AL |
| 1949 | George Kell | DET | AL |
| 1949 | George Kell | DET | ML |
| 1949 | Howie Pollet | STL | NL |
| 1949 | Howie Pollet | STL | ML |
| 1949 | Pee Wee Reese | BRO | NL |
| 1949 | Yogi Berra | NYY | AL |
| 1949 | Yogi Berra | NYY | ML |
| 1949 | Tommy Henrich | NYY | AL |
| 1949 | Tommy Henrich | NYY | ML |
| 1949 | Ralph Kiner | PIT | NL |
| 1949 | Jackie Robinson | BRO | ML |
| 1949 | Jackie Robinson | BRO | NL |
| 1949 | Warren Spahn | BSN | ML |
| 1949 | Warren Spahn | BSN | NL |
| 1949 | Vic Raschi | NYY | AL |
| 1949 | Vic Raschi | NYY | ML |
| 1949 | Roy Campanella | BRO | NL |
| 1949 | Sid Gordon | NY1 | NL |
| 1949 | Gil Hodges | BRO | NL |
| 1949 | Cass Michaels | CHW | AL |
| 1949 | Don Newcombe | BRO | NL |
| 1949 | Joe Page | NYY | AL |
| 1949 | Mel Parnell | BOS | ML |
| 1949 | Mel Parnell | BOS | AL |
| 1949 | Vic Wertz | DET | ML |
| 1949 | Vic Wertz | DET | AL |
| 1948 | Joe DiMaggio | NYY | AL |
| 1948 | Joe DiMaggio | NYY | ML |
| 1948 | Johnny Mize | NY1 | NL |
| 1948 | Johnny Mize | NY1 | ML |
| 1948 | Joe Gordon | CLE | AL |
| 1948 | Joe Gordon | CLE | ML |
| 1948 | Ted Williams | BOS | AL |
| 1948 | Ted Williams | BOS | ML |
| 1948 | Enos Slaughter | STL | NL |
| 1948 | Stan Musial | STL | ML |
| 1948 | Stan Musial | STL | NL |
| 1948 | Hal Newhouser | DET | ML |
| 1948 | Hal Newhouser | DET | AL |
| 1948 | Harry Brecheen | STL | NL |
| 1948 | Andy Pafko | CHC | ML |
| 1948 | Andy Pafko | CHC | NL |
| 1948 | Lou Boudreau | CLE | ML |
| 1948 | Lou Boudreau | CLE | AL |
| 1948 | George Kell | DET | AL |
| 1948 | Johnny Sain | BSN | ML |
| 1948 | Johnny Sain | BSN | NL |
| 1948 | Tommy Henrich | NYY | AL |
| 1948 | Ralph Kiner | PIT | NL |
| 1948 | Jackie Robinson | BRO | NL |
| 1948 | Al Dark | BSN | NL |
| 1948 | Ferris Fain | PHA | AL |
| 1948 | Bob Lemon | CLE | ML |
| 1948 | Bob Lemon | CLE | AL |
| 1948 | Phil Masi | BSN | NL |
| 1948 | Vic Raschi | NYY | AL |
| 1948 | Johnny Schmitz | CHC | NL |
| 1948 | Birdie Tebbetts | BOS | ML |
| 1948 | Birdie Tebbetts | BOS | AL |
| 1947 | Joe DiMaggio | NYY | ML |
| 1947 | Joe DiMaggio | NYY | AL |
| 1947 | Johnny Mize | NY1 | ML |
| 1947 | Johnny Mize | NY1 | NL |
| 1947 | Bob Feller | CLE | ML |
| 1947 | Bob Feller | CLE | AL |
| 1947 | Joe Gordon | CLE | AL |
| 1947 | Joe Gordon | CLE | ML |
| 1947 | Ted Williams | BOS | AL |
| 1947 | Ted Williams | BOS | ML |
| 1947 | Enos Slaughter | STL | NL |
| 1947 | Enos Slaughter | STL | ML |
| 1947 | Bob Elliott | BSN | NL |
| 1947 | Bob Elliott | BSN | ML |
| 1947 | Hal Newhouser | DET | AL |
| 1947 | Hal Newhouser | DET | ML |
| 1947 | Lou Boudreau | CLE | ML |
| 1947 | Lou Boudreau | CLE | AL |
| 1947 | George Kell | DET | AL |
| 1947 | Pee Wee Reese | BRO | NL |
| 1947 | Eddie Stanky | BRO | NL |
| 1947 | Yogi Berra | NYY | AL |
| 1947 | Ewell Blackwell | CIN | NL |
| 1947 | Ewell Blackwell | CIN | ML |
| 1947 | Ralph Branca | BRO | NL |
| 1947 | Bruce Edwards | BRO | ML |
| 1947 | Bruce Edwards | BRO | NL |
| 1947 | Tommy Henrich | NYY | AL |
| 1947 | Ralph Kiner | PIT | NL |
| 1947 | Willard Marshall | NY1 | NL |
| 1947 | George McQuinn | NYY | AL |
| 1947 | Allie Reynolds | NYY | AL |
| 1947 | Warren Spahn | BSN | NL |
| 1946 | Joe DiMaggio | NYY | AL |
| 1946 | Joe DiMaggio | NYY | ML |
| 1946 | Bob Feller | CLE | ML |
| 1946 | Bob Feller | CLE | AL |
| 1946 | Ted Williams | BOS | ML |
| 1946 | Ted Williams | BOS | AL |
| 1946 | Enos Slaughter | STL | ML |
| 1946 | Enos Slaughter | STL | NL |
| 1946 | Stan Musial | STL | ML |
| 1946 | Stan Musial | STL | NL |
| 1946 | Bobby Doerr | BOS | ML |
| 1946 | Bobby Doerr | BOS | AL |
| 1946 | Hal Newhouser | DET | AL |
| 1946 | Hal Newhouser | DET | ML |
| 1946 | Harry Brecheen | STL | NL |
| 1946 | Phil Cavarretta | CHC | NL |
| 1946 | Roy Cullenbine | DET | AL |
| 1946 | Dave Ferriss | BOS | AL |
| 1946 | Whitey Kurowski | STL | ML |
| 1946 | Whitey Kurowski | STL | NL |
| 1946 | Lou Boudreau | CLE | ML |
| 1946 | Lou Boudreau | CLE | AL |
| 1946 | Del Ennis | PHI | NL |
| 1946 | George Kell | DET | AL |
| 1946 | Clyde McCullough | CHC | NL |
| 1946 | Howie Pollet | STL | ML |
| 1946 | Howie Pollet | STL | NL |
| 1946 | Pee Wee Reese | BRO | NL |
| 1946 | Aaron Robinson | NYY | ML |
| 1946 | Aaron Robinson | NYY | AL |
| 1946 | Johnny Sain | BSN | NL |
| 1946 | Eddie Stanky | BRO | NL |
| 1946 | Mickey Vernon | WSN | AL |
| 1945 | Al Lopez | PIT | NL |
| 1945 | Hank Greenberg | DET | ML |
| 1945 | Hank Greenberg | DET | AL |
| 1945 | Jeff Heath | CLE | AL |
| 1945 | Marty Marion | STL | NL |
| 1945 | Vern Stephens | SLA | AL |
| 1945 | Vern Stephens | SLA | ML |
| 1945 | Hal Newhouser | DET | ML |
| 1945 | Hal Newhouser | DET | AL |
| 1945 | Snuffy Stirnweiss | NYY | AL |
| 1945 | Snuffy Stirnweiss | NYY | ML |
| 1945 | Emil Verban | STL | NL |
| 1945 | Dixie Walker | BRO | NL |
| 1945 | Dixie Walker | BRO | ML |
| 1945 | Red Barrett | BSN | NL |
| 1945 | Hank Borowy | CHC | ML |
| 1945 | Hank Borowy | CHC | NL |
| 1945 | Harry Brecheen | STL | NL |
| 1945 | Harry Brecheen | STL | ML |
| 1945 | Phil Cavarretta | CHC | NL |
| 1945 | Phil Cavarretta | CHC | ML |
| 1945 | Tony Cuccinello | CHW | AL |
| 1945 | Roy Cullenbine | CLE | AL |
| 1945 | Nick Etten | NYY | AL |
| 1945 | Dave Ferriss | BOS | AL |
| 1945 | Dave Ferriss | BOS | ML |
| 1945 | Steve Gromek | CLE | AL |
| 1945 | Tommy Holmes | BSN | NL |
| 1945 | Whitey Kurowski | STL | ML |
| 1945 | Whitey Kurowski | STL | NL |
| 1945 | Andy Pafko | CHC | ML |
| 1945 | Andy Pafko | CHC | NL |
| 1945 | Paul Richards | DET | ML |
| 1945 | Paul Richards | DET | AL |
| 1945 | Roger Wolff | WSN | AL |
| 1945 | Hank Wyse | CHC | NL |
| 1944 | Joe Medwick | NY1 | NL |
| 1944 | Pete Fox | BOS | AL |
| 1944 | Bucky Walters | CIN | ML |
| 1944 | Bucky Walters | CIN | NL |
| 1944 | Frankie Hayes | PHA | AL |
| 1944 | Bill Nicholson | CHC | NL |
| 1944 | Bill Nicholson | CHC | ML |
| 1944 | Mort Cooper | STL | ML |
| 1944 | Mort Cooper | STL | NL |
| 1944 | Tex Hughson | BOS | AL |
| 1944 | Ken Keltner | CLE | AL |
| 1944 | Marty Marion | STL | ML |
| 1944 | Marty Marion | STL | NL |
| 1944 | Stan Spence | WSN | AL |
| 1944 | Vern Stephens | SLA | AL |
| 1944 | Walker Cooper | STL | ML |
| 1944 | Walker Cooper | STL | NL |
| 1944 | Stan Musial | STL | ML |
| 1944 | Stan Musial | STL | NL |
| 1944 | Dizzy Trout | DET | AL |
| 1944 | Dick Wakefield | DET | AL |
| 1944 | Dick Wakefield | DET | ML |
| 1944 | Rudy York | DET | ML |
| 1944 | Rudy York | DET | AL |
| 1944 | Bob Elliott | PIT | ML |
| 1944 | Bob Elliott | PIT | NL |
| 1944 | Hal Newhouser | DET | AL |
| 1944 | Hal Newhouser | DET | ML |
| 1944 | Ray Sanders | STL | NL |
| 1944 | Snuffy Stirnweiss | NYY | AL |
| 1944 | Snuffy Stirnweiss | NYY | ML |
| 1944 | Emil Verban | STL | NL |
| 1944 | Bill Voiselle | NY1 | NL |
| 1943 | Bill Dickey | NYY | AL |
| 1943 | Bill Dickey | NYY | ML |
| 1943 | Billy Herman | BRO | NL |
| 1943 | Billy Herman | BRO | ML |
| 1943 | Arky Vaughan | BRO | NL |
| 1943 | Luke Appling | CHW | AL |
| 1943 | Frank McCormick | CIN | NL |
| 1943 | Joe Gordon | NYY | AL |
| 1943 | Charlie Keller | NYY | ML |
| 1943 | Charlie Keller | NYY | AL |
| 1943 | Bill Nicholson | CHC | ML |
| 1943 | Bill Nicholson | CHC | NL |
| 1943 | Elmer Riddle | CIN | NL |
| 1943 | Spud Chandler | NYY | AL |
| 1943 | Spud Chandler | NYY | ML |
| 1943 | Mort Cooper | STL | ML |
| 1943 | Mort Cooper | STL | NL |
| 1943 | Marty Marion | STL | ML |
| 1943 | Marty Marion | STL | NL |
| 1943 | Stan Spence | WSN | AL |
| 1943 | Walker Cooper | STL | NL |
| 1943 | Vince DiMaggio | PIT | NL |
| 1943 | Billy Johnson | NYY | AL |
| 1943 | Billy Johnson | NYY | ML |
| 1943 | Stan Musial | STL | ML |
| 1943 | Stan Musial | STL | NL |
| 1943 | Rip Sewell | PIT | ML |
| 1943 | Rip Sewell | PIT | NL |
| 1943 | Al Smith | CLE | AL |
| 1943 | Dizzy Trout | DET | AL |
| 1943 | Dick Wakefield | DET | AL |
| 1943 | Rudy York | DET | AL |
| 1943 | Rudy York | DET | ML |
| 1942 | Bill Dickey | NYY | AL |
| 1942 | Bill Dickey | NYY | ML |
| 1942 | Joe Medwick | BRO | NL |
| 1942 | Arky Vaughan | BRO | NL |
| 1942 | Joe DiMaggio | NYY | ML |
| 1942 | Joe DiMaggio | NYY | AL |
| 1942 | Johnny Mize | NY1 | NL |
| 1942 | Johnny Mize | NY1 | ML |
| 1942 | Ernie Lombardi | BSN | NL |
| 1942 | Johnny Vander Meer | CIN | ML |
| 1942 | Johnny Vander Meer | CIN | NL |
| 1942 | Joe Gordon | NYY | ML |
| 1942 | Joe Gordon | NYY | AL |
| 1942 | Ted Williams | BOS | ML |
| 1942 | Ted Williams | BOS | AL |
| 1942 | Jimmy Brown | STL | NL |
| 1942 | Pete Reiser | BRO | NL |
| 1942 | Enos Slaughter | STL | ML |
| 1942 | Enos Slaughter | STL | NL |
| 1942 | Whit Wyatt | BRO | ML |
| 1942 | Whit Wyatt | BRO | NL |
| 1942 | Jim Bagby | CLE | AL |
| 1942 | Johnny Beazley | STL | NL |
| 1942 | Tiny Bonham | NYY | AL |
| 1942 | Tiny Bonham | NYY | ML |
| 1942 | Spud Chandler | NYY | AL |
| 1942 | Mort Cooper | STL | NL |
| 1942 | Mort Cooper | STL | ML |
| 1942 | Buddy Hassett | NYY | AL |
| 1942 | Tommy Hughes | PHI | NL |
| 1942 | Tex Hughson | BOS | AL |
| 1942 | Tex Hughson | BOS | ML |
| 1942 | Ken Keltner | CLE | ML |
| 1942 | Ken Keltner | CLE | AL |
| 1942 | Phil Marchildon | PHA | AL |
| 1942 | Marty Marion | STL | NL |
| 1942 | Stan Spence | WSN | AL |
| 1942 | Vern Stephens | SLA | ML |
| 1942 | Vern Stephens | SLA | AL |
| 1941 | Jimmie Foxx | BOS | AL |
| 1941 | Bill Dickey | NYY | ML |
| 1941 | Bill Dickey | NYY | AL |
| 1941 | Lon Warneke | STL | NL |
| 1941 | Al Lopez | PIT | NL |
| 1941 | Joe Medwick | BRO | NL |
| 1941 | Joe DiMaggio | NYY | AL |
| 1941 | Joe DiMaggio | NYY | ML |
| 1941 | Red Ruffing | NYY | AL |
| 1941 | Jeff Heath | CLE | AL |
| 1941 | Jeff Heath | CLE | ML |
| 1941 | Bob Feller | CLE | AL |
| 1941 | Bob Feller | CLE | ML |
| 1941 | Joe Gordon | NYY | AL |
| 1941 | Joe Gordon | NYY | ML |
| 1941 | Dutch Leonard | WSN | AL |
| 1941 | Ted Williams | BOS | ML |
| 1941 | Ted Williams | BOS | AL |
| 1941 | Jimmy Brown | STL | NL |
| 1941 | Jimmy Brown | STL | ML |
| 1941 | Dolph Camilli | BRO | ML |
| 1941 | Dolph Camilli | BRO | NL |
| 1941 | Frank Crespi | STL | NL |
| 1941 | Kirby Higbe | BRO | NL |
| 1941 | Billy Jurges | NY1 | NL |
| 1941 | Thornton Lee | CHW | ML |
| 1941 | Thornton Lee | CHW | AL |
| 1941 | Dick Newsome | BOS | AL |
| 1941 | Pete Reiser | BRO | NL |
| 1941 | Elmer Riddle | CIN | NL |
| 1941 | Elmer Riddle | CIN | ML |
| 1941 | Enos Slaughter | STL | NL |
| 1941 | Jim Tabor | BOS | AL |
| 1941 | Cecil Travis | WSN | AL |
| 1941 | Cecil Travis | WSN | ML |
| 1941 | Ernie White | STL | ML |
| 1941 | Ernie White | STL | NL |
| 1941 | Whit Wyatt | BRO | ML |
| 1941 | Whit Wyatt | BRO | NL |
| 1940 | Jimmie Foxx | BOS | AL |
| 1940 | Paul Derringer | CIN | NL |
| 1940 | Paul Derringer | CIN | ML |
| 1940 | Billy Herman | CHC | NL |
| 1940 | Joe Medwick | BRO | NL |
| 1940 | Billy Werber | CIN | NL |
| 1940 | Hank Greenberg | DET | AL |
| 1940 | Hank Greenberg | DET | ML |
| 1940 | Luke Appling | CHW | ML |
| 1940 | Luke Appling | CHW | AL |
| 1940 | Joe DiMaggio | NYY | AL |
| 1940 | Joe DiMaggio | NYY | ML |
| 1940 | Johnny Mize | STL | ML |
| 1940 | Johnny Mize | STL | NL |
| 1940 | Harry Danning | NY1 | ML |
| 1940 | Harry Danning | NY1 | NL |
| 1940 | Bobo Newsom | DET | AL |
| 1940 | Bobo Newsom | DET | ML |
| 1940 | Bob Feller | CLE | ML |
| 1940 | Bob Feller | CLE | AL |
| 1940 | Joe Gordon | NYY | AL |
| 1940 | Joe Gordon | NYY | ML |
| 1940 | Hank Leiber | CHC | NL |
| 1940 | Bucky Walters | CIN | NL |
| 1940 | Bucky Walters | CIN | ML |
| 1940 | Harlond Clift | SLA | AL |
| 1940 | Harlond Clift | SLA | ML |
| 1940 | Frankie Hayes | PHA | AL |
| 1940 | Charlie Keller | NYY | AL |
| 1940 | Eddie Miller | BSN | NL |
| 1940 | Bill Nicholson | CHC | ML |
| 1940 | Bill Nicholson | CHC | NL |
| 1939 | Jimmie Foxx | BOS | AL |
| 1939 | Jimmie Foxx | BOS | ML |
| 1939 | Joe Cronin | BOS | AL |
| 1939 | Joe Cronin | BOS | ML |
| 1939 | Paul Derringer | CIN | NL |
| 1939 | Paul Derringer | CIN | ML |
| 1939 | Bill Dickey | NYY | AL |
| 1939 | Bill Dickey | NYY | ML |
| 1939 | Joe Medwick | STL | ML |
| 1939 | Joe Medwick | STL | NL |
| 1939 | Arky Vaughan | PIT | NL |
| 1939 | Mel Ott | NY1 | NL |
| 1939 | Joe DiMaggio | NYY | AL |
| 1939 | Joe DiMaggio | NYY | ML |
| 1939 | Red Rolfe | NYY | ML |
| 1939 | Red Rolfe | NYY | AL |
| 1939 | Red Ruffing | NYY | AL |
| 1939 | Red Ruffing | NYY | ML |
| 1939 | Harry Danning | NY1 | NL |
| 1939 | Frank McCormick | CIN | NL |
| 1939 | Curt Davis | STL | NL |
| 1939 | Curt Davis | STL | ML |
| 1939 | Bob Feller | CLE | AL |
| 1939 | Bob Feller | CLE | ML |
| 1939 | Lonny Frey | CIN | NL |
| 1939 | Joe Gordon | NYY | AL |
| 1939 | Joe Gordon | NYY | ML |
| 1939 | Bob Johnson | PHA | AL |
| 1939 | Cookie Lavagetto | BRO | NL |
| 1939 | Hank Leiber | CHC | NL |
| 1939 | Dutch Leonard | WSN | AL |
| 1939 | Bucky Walters | CIN | ML |
| 1939 | Bucky Walters | CIN | NL |
| 1939 | Ted Williams | BOS | ML |
| 1939 | Ted Williams | BOS | AL |
| 1938 | Lefty Grove | BOS | AL |
| 1938 | Jimmie Foxx | BOS | ML |
| 1938 | Jimmie Foxx | BOS | AL |
| 1938 | Charlie Gehringer | DET | ML |
| 1938 | Charlie Gehringer | DET | AL |
| 1938 | Carl Hubbell | NY1 | NL |
| 1938 | Earl Averill | CLE | AL |
| 1938 | Joe Cronin | BOS | AL |
| 1938 | Paul Derringer | CIN | ML |
| 1938 | Paul Derringer | CIN | NL |
| 1938 | Bill Dickey | NYY | AL |
| 1938 | Bill Dickey | NYY | ML |
| 1938 | Lefty Gomez | NYY | AL |
| 1938 | Billy Herman | CHC | NL |
| 1938 | Joe Medwick | STL | ML |
| 1938 | Joe Medwick | STL | NL |
| 1938 | Arky Vaughan | PIT | ML |
| 1938 | Arky Vaughan | PIT | NL |
| 1938 | Mel Ott | NY1 | NL |
| 1938 | Mel Ott | NY1 | ML |
| 1938 | Johnny Allen | CLE | AL |
| 1938 | Joe DiMaggio | NYY | AL |
| 1938 | Joe DiMaggio | NYY | ML |
| 1938 | Stan Hack | CHC | NL |
| 1938 | Red Rolfe | NYY | AL |
| 1938 | Red Rolfe | NYY | ML |
| 1938 | Red Ruffing | NYY | ML |
| 1938 | Red Ruffing | NYY | AL |
| 1938 | Jim Turner | BSN | NL |
| 1938 | Harry Danning | NY1 | NL |
| 1938 | Ival Goodman | CIN | NL |
| 1938 | Jeff Heath | CLE | AL |
| 1938 | Rollie Hemsley | CLE | AL |
| 1938 | Bill Lee | CHC | NL |
| 1938 | Ernie Lombardi | CIN | NL |
| 1938 | Frank McCormick | CIN | NL |
| 1938 | Bobo Newsom | SLA | AL |
| 1938 | Johnny Vander Meer | CIN | NL |
| 1938 | Johnny Vander Meer | CIN | ML |
| 1937 | Gabby Hartnett | CHC | NL |
| 1937 | Lefty Grove | BOS | AL |
| 1937 | Lou Gehrig | NYY | AL |
| 1937 | Lou Gehrig | NYY | ML |
| 1937 | Paul Waner | PIT | ML |
| 1937 | Paul Waner | PIT | NL |
| 1937 | Charlie Gehringer | DET | ML |
| 1937 | Charlie Gehringer | DET | AL |
| 1937 | Carl Hubbell | NY1 | ML |
| 1937 | Carl Hubbell | NY1 | NL |
| 1937 | Bill Dickey | NYY | AL |
| 1937 | Bill Dickey | NYY | ML |
| 1937 | Lefty Gomez | NYY | ML |
| 1937 | Lefty Gomez | NYY | AL |
| 1937 | Billy Herman | CHC | NL |
| 1937 | Lon Warneke | STL | ML |
| 1937 | Lon Warneke | STL | NL |
| 1937 | Pinky Higgins | BOS | AL |
| 1937 | Joe Medwick | STL | NL |
| 1937 | Joe Medwick | STL | ML |
| 1937 | Arky Vaughan | PIT | NL |
| 1937 | Joe Vosmik | SLA | AL |
| 1937 | Johnny Allen | CLE | AL |
| 1937 | Luke Appling | CHW | AL |
| 1937 | Luke Appling | CHW | ML |
| 1937 | Joe DiMaggio | NYY | AL |
| 1937 | Joe DiMaggio | NYY | ML |
| 1937 | Wally Moses | PHA | AL |
| 1937 | Frank Demaree | CHC | NL |
| 1937 | Lou Fette | BSN | NL |
| 1937 | Lou Fette | BSN | ML |
| 1937 | Roxie Lawson | DET | AL |
| 1937 | Johnny Mize | STL | NL |
| 1937 | Jim Turner | BSN | NL |
| 1937 | Pinky Whitney | PHI | ML |
| 1937 | Pinky Whitney | PHI | NL |
| 1936 | Gabby Hartnett | CHC | NL |
| 1936 | Kiki Cuyler | CIN | NL |
| 1936 | Lou Gehrig | NYY | AL |
| 1936 | Lou Gehrig | NYY | ML |
| 1936 | Paul Waner | PIT | ML |
| 1936 | Paul Waner | PIT | NL |
| 1936 | Wes Ferrell | BOS | AL |
| 1936 | Charlie Gehringer | DET | AL |
| 1936 | Charlie Gehringer | DET | ML |
| 1936 | Carl Hubbell | NY1 | NL |
| 1936 | Carl Hubbell | NY1 | ML |
| 1936 | Earl Averill | CLE | AL |
| 1936 | Earl Averill | CLE | ML |
| 1936 | Dizzy Dean | STL | ML |
| 1936 | Dizzy Dean | STL | NL |
| 1936 | Bill Dickey | NYY | AL |
| 1936 | Bill Dickey | NYY | ML |
| 1936 | Billy Herman | CHC | NL |
| 1936 | Tommy Bridges | DET | ML |
| 1936 | Tommy Bridges | DET | AL |
| 1936 | Joe Medwick | STL | NL |
| 1936 | Arky Vaughan | PIT | NL |
| 1936 | Johnny Allen | CLE | AL |
| 1936 | Luke Appling | CHW | ML |
| 1936 | Luke Appling | CHW | AL |
| 1936 | Joe DiMaggio | NYY | AL |
| 1936 | Joe DiMaggio | NYY | ML |
| 1936 | Larry French | CHC | NL |
| 1936 | Stan Hack | CHC | ML |
| 1936 | Stan Hack | CHC | NL |
| 1936 | Vern Kennedy | CHW | AL |
| 1936 | Vern Kennedy | CHW | ML |
| 1936 | Danny MacFayden | BSN | NL |
| 1936 | Wally Moses | PHA | AL |
| 1936 | Marv Owen | DET | AL |
| 1936 | Gus Suhr | PIT | NL |
| 1935 | Gabby Hartnett | CHC | NL |
| 1935 | Mickey Cochrane | DET | ML |
| 1935 | Mickey Cochrane | DET | AL |
| 1935 | Lefty Grove | BOS | AL |
| 1935 | Bill Terry | NY1 | NL |
| 1935 | Wes Ferrell | BOS | ML |
| 1935 | Wes Ferrell | BOS | AL |
| 1935 | Charlie Gehringer | DET | AL |
| 1935 | Charlie Gehringer | DET | ML |
| 1935 | Carl Hubbell | NY1 | ML |
| 1935 | Carl Hubbell | NY1 | NL |
| 1935 | Joe Cronin | BOS | AL |
| 1935 | Paul Derringer | CIN | NL |
| 1935 | Dizzy Dean | STL | ML |
| 1935 | Dizzy Dean | STL | NL |
| 1935 | Billy Herman | CHC | NL |
| 1935 | Lon Warneke | CHC | NL |
| 1935 | Wally Berger | BSN | NL |
| 1935 | Wally Berger | BSN | ML |
| 1935 | Tommy Bridges | DET | ML |
| 1935 | Tommy Bridges | DET | AL |
| 1935 | Pinky Higgins | PHA | AL |
| 1935 | Joe Medwick | STL | ML |
| 1935 | Joe Medwick | STL | NL |
| 1935 | Arky Vaughan | PIT | NL |
| 1935 | Arky Vaughan | PIT | ML |
| 1935 | Mel Harder | CLE | AL |
| 1935 | Mel Ott | NY1 | NL |
| 1935 | Mel Ott | NY1 | ML |
| 1935 | Doc Cramer | PHA | AL |
| 1935 | Pete Fox | DET | AL |
| 1935 | Hank Greenberg | DET | ML |
| 1935 | Hank Greenberg | DET | AL |
| 1935 | Pepper Martin | STL | ML |
| 1935 | Pepper Martin | STL | NL |
| 1935 | Joe Vosmik | CLE | AL |
| 1934 | Frankie Frisch | STL | NL |
| 1934 | Gabby Hartnett | CHC | NL |
| 1934 | Pie Traynor | PIT | ML |
| 1934 | Pie Traynor | PIT | NL |
| 1934 | Mickey Cochrane | DET | ML |
| 1934 | Mickey Cochrane | DET | AL |
| 1934 | Al Simmons | CHW | AL |
| 1934 | Al Simmons | CHW | ML |
| 1934 | Heinie Manush | WSN | AL |
| 1934 | Lou Gehrig | NYY | AL |
| 1934 | Lou Gehrig | NYY | ML |
| 1934 | Bill Terry | NY1 | NL |
| 1934 | Paul Waner | PIT | NL |
| 1934 | Paul Waner | PIT | ML |
| 1934 | Charlie Gehringer | DET | ML |
| 1934 | Charlie Gehringer | DET | AL |
| 1934 | Carl Hubbell | NY1 | ML |
| 1934 | Carl Hubbell | NY1 | NL |
| 1934 | Dizzy Dean | STL | ML |
| 1934 | Dizzy Dean | STL | NL |
| 1934 | Lefty Gomez | NYY | AL |
| 1934 | Lefty Gomez | NYY | ML |
| 1934 | Lon Warneke | CHC | NL |
| 1934 | Tommy Bridges | DET | AL |
| 1934 | Arky Vaughan | PIT | ML |
| 1934 | Arky Vaughan | PIT | NL |
| 1934 | Sam West | SLA | AL |
| 1934 | Mel Harder | CLE | AL |
| 1934 | Bill Knickerbocker | CLE | AL |
| 1934 | Jo-Jo Moore | NY1 | NL |
| 1934 | Mel Ott | NY1 | NL |
| 1934 | Mel Ott | NY1 | ML |
| 1934 | Schoolboy Rowe | DET | AL |
| 1934 | Schoolboy Rowe | DET | ML |
| 1934 | Hal Schumacher | NY1 | NL |
| 1934 | Billy Werber | BOS | AL |
| 1933 | Frankie Frisch | STL | NL |
| 1933 | Pie Traynor | PIT | NL |
| 1933 | Pie Traynor | PIT | ML |
| 1933 | Mickey Cochrane | PHA | AL |
| 1933 | Mickey Cochrane | PHA | ML |
| 1933 | Al Simmons | CHW | AL |
| 1933 | Al Simmons | CHW | ML |
| 1933 | Lefty Grove | PHA | ML |
| 1933 | Lefty Grove | PHA | AL |
| 1933 | Bill Terry | NY1 | NL |
| 1933 | General Crowder | WSN | AL |
| 1933 | Jimmie Foxx | PHA | AL |
| 1933 | Jimmie Foxx | PHA | ML |
| 1933 | Charlie Gehringer | DET | AL |
| 1933 | Charlie Gehringer | DET | ML |
| 1933 | Carl Hubbell | NY1 | ML |
| 1933 | Carl Hubbell | NY1 | NL |
| 1933 | Earl Averill | CLE | AL |
| 1933 | Joe Cronin | WSN | ML |
| 1933 | Joe Cronin | WSN | AL |
| 1933 | Chuck Klein | PHI | NL |
| 1933 | Chuck Klein | PHI | ML |
| 1933 | Dizzy Dean | STL | ML |
| 1933 | Dizzy Dean | STL | NL |
| 1933 | Lon Warneke | CHC | NL |
| 1933 | Wally Berger | BSN | NL |
| 1933 | Wally Berger | BSN | ML |
| 1933 | Tommy Bridges | DET | AL |
| 1933 | Ben Cantwell | BSN | NL |
| 1933 | Pinky Higgins | PHA | AL |
| 1933 | Al Lopez | BRO | NL |
| 1933 | Joe Medwick | STL | NL |
| 1933 | Arky Vaughan | PIT | NL |
| 1933 | Sam West | SLA | AL |
| 1933 | Earl Whitehill | WSN | ML |
| 1933 | Earl Whitehill | WSN | AL |
| 1932 | Babe Ruth | NYY | AL |
| 1932 | Gabby Hartnett | CHC | NL |
| 1932 | Pie Traynor | PIT | NL |
| 1932 | Pie Traynor | PIT | ML |
| 1932 | Mickey Cochrane | PHA | ML |
| 1932 | Mickey Cochrane | PHA | AL |
| 1932 | Al Simmons | PHA | AL |
| 1932 | Lefty Grove | PHA | AL |
| 1932 | Lefty Grove | PHA | ML |
| 1932 | Willie Kamm | CLE | AL |
| 1932 | Bill Terry | NY1 | NL |
| 1932 | Lloyd Waner | PIT | NL |
| 1932 | Lloyd Waner | PIT | ML |
| 1932 | General Crowder | WSN | ML |
| 1932 | General Crowder | WSN | AL |
| 1932 | Wes Ferrell | CLE | AL |
| 1932 | Jimmie Foxx | PHA | ML |
| 1932 | Jimmie Foxx | PHA | AL |
| 1932 | Charlie Gehringer | DET | AL |
| 1932 | Charlie Gehringer | DET | ML |
| 1932 | Carl Hubbell | NY1 | NL |
| 1932 | Lefty O'Doul | BRO | NL |
| 1932 | Lefty O'Doul | BRO | ML |
| 1932 | Earl Averill | CLE | AL |
| 1932 | Joe Cronin | WSN | AL |
| 1932 | Joe Cronin | WSN | ML |
| 1932 | Chuck Klein | PHI | ML |
| 1932 | Chuck Klein | PHI | NL |
| 1932 | Dick Bartell | PHI | NL |
| 1932 | Watson Clark | BRO | NL |
| 1932 | Dizzy Dean | STL | NL |
| 1932 | Lefty Gomez | NYY | AL |
| 1932 | Lefty Gomez | NYY | ML |
| 1932 | Billy Herman | CHC | NL |
| 1932 | Lon Warneke | CHC | ML |
| 1932 | Lon Warneke | CHC | NL |
| 1931 | Babe Ruth | NYY | AL |
| 1931 | Babe Ruth | NYY | ML |
| 1931 | Frankie Frisch | STL | NL |
| 1931 | Frankie Frisch | STL | ML |
| 1931 | Gabby Hartnett | CHC | NL |
| 1931 | Travis Jackson | NY1 | NL |
| 1931 | Pie Traynor | PIT | NL |
| 1931 | Pie Traynor | PIT | ML |
| 1931 | Mickey Cochrane | PHA | ML |
| 1931 | Mickey Cochrane | PHA | AL |
| 1931 | Kiki Cuyler | CHC | NL |
| 1931 | Kiki Cuyler | CHC | ML |
| 1931 | Al Simmons | PHA | AL |
| 1931 | Al Simmons | PHA | ML |
| 1931 | Lefty Grove | PHA | ML |
| 1931 | Lefty Grove | PHA | AL |
| 1931 | Willie Kamm | CHW | AL |
| 1931 | Lou Gehrig | NYY | AL |
| 1931 | Lou Gehrig | NYY | ML |
| 1931 | Bill Terry | NY1 | NL |
| 1931 | Chick Hafey | STL | NL |
| 1931 | George Earnshaw | PHA | ML |
| 1931 | George Earnshaw | PHA | AL |
| 1931 | Wes Ferrell | CLE | AL |
| 1931 | Wes Ferrell | CLE | ML |
| 1931 | Earl Averill | CLE | AL |
| 1931 | Joe Cronin | WSN | AL |
| 1931 | Joe Cronin | WSN | ML |
| 1931 | Bill Hallahan | STL | NL |
| 1931 | Ed Brandt | BSN | ML |
| 1931 | Ed Brandt | BSN | NL |
| 1931 | Paul Derringer | STL | NL |
| 1931 | Freddie Fitzsimmons | NY1 | NL |
| 1931 | Chuck Klein | PHI | NL |
| 1931 | Oscar Melillo | SLA | AL |
| 1931 | Rube Walberg | PHA | AL |
| 1930 | Babe Ruth | NYY | ML |
| 1930 | Babe Ruth | NYY | AL |
| 1930 | Frankie Frisch | STL | ML |
| 1930 | Frankie Frisch | STL | NL |
| 1930 | Dazzy Vance | BRO | NL |
| 1930 | Gabby Hartnett | CHC | NL |
| 1930 | Travis Jackson | NY1 | NL |
| 1930 | Mickey Cochrane | PHA | ML |
| 1930 | Mickey Cochrane | PHA | AL |
| 1930 | Kiki Cuyler | CHC | NL |
| 1930 | Ted Lyons | CHW | AL |
| 1930 | Ted Lyons | CHW | ML |
| 1930 | Al Simmons | PHA | AL |
| 1930 | Al Simmons | PHA | ML |
| 1930 | Lefty Grove | PHA | ML |
| 1930 | Lefty Grove | PHA | AL |
| 1930 | Ray Kremer | PIT | NL |
| 1930 | Hack Wilson | CHC | ML |
| 1930 | Hack Wilson | CHC | NL |
| 1930 | Lou Gehrig | NYY | AL |
| 1930 | Tony Lazzeri | NYY | AL |
| 1930 | Bill Terry | NY1 | NL |
| 1930 | Bill Terry | NY1 | ML |
| 1930 | Chick Hafey | STL | NL |
| 1930 | Freddie Lindstrom | NY1 | NL |
| 1930 | Freddie Lindstrom | NY1 | ML |
| 1930 | George Earnshaw | PHA | AL |
| 1930 | Wes Ferrell | CLE | AL |
| 1930 | Wes Ferrell | CLE | ML |
| 1930 | Charlie Gehringer | DET | AL |
| 1930 | Pat Malone | CHC | ML |
| 1930 | Pat Malone | CHC | NL |
| 1930 | Earl Averill | CLE | AL |
| 1930 | Joe Cronin | WSN | AL |
| 1930 | Joe Cronin | WSN | ML |
| 1930 | Bill Hallahan | STL | NL |
| 1929 | Rogers Hornsby | CHC | ML |
| 1929 | Rogers Hornsby | CHC | NL |
| 1929 | Babe Ruth | NYY | AL |
| 1929 | Babe Ruth | NYY | ML |
| 1929 | Burleigh Grimes | PIT | NL |
| 1929 | Travis Jackson | NY1 | NL |
| 1929 | Travis Jackson | NY1 | ML |
| 1929 | Pie Traynor | PIT | NL |
| 1929 | Pie Traynor | PIT | ML |
| 1929 | Mickey Cochrane | PHA | AL |
| 1929 | Mickey Cochrane | PHA | ML |
| 1929 | Al Simmons | PHA | AL |
| 1929 | Al Simmons | PHA | ML |
| 1929 | Lefty Grove | PHA | AL |
| 1929 | Lefty Grove | PHA | ML |
| 1929 | Hack Wilson | CHC | ML |
| 1929 | Hack Wilson | CHC | NL |
| 1929 | Bill Terry | NY1 | ML |
| 1929 | Bill Terry | NY1 | NL |
| 1929 | Jimmie Wilson | STL | NL |
| 1929 | Chick Hafey | STL | NL |
| 1929 | Earle Combs | NYY | AL |
| 1929 | Jimmy Dykes | PHA | AL |
| 1929 | George Earnshaw | PHA | ML |
| 1929 | George Earnshaw | PHA | AL |
| 1929 | Wes Ferrell | CLE | AL |
| 1929 | Lew Fonseca | CLE | AL |
| 1929 | Charlie Gehringer | DET | AL |
| 1929 | Sam Gray | SLA | AL |
| 1929 | Carl Hubbell | NY1 | NL |
| 1929 | Red Kress | SLA | AL |
| 1929 | Red Lucas | CIN | ML |
| 1929 | Red Lucas | CIN | NL |
| 1929 | Pat Malone | CHC | NL |
| 1929 | Pat Malone | CHC | ML |
| 1929 | Lefty O'Doul | PHI | NL |
| 1928 | Rogers Hornsby | BSN | ML |
| 1928 | Rogers Hornsby | BSN | NL |
| 1928 | Babe Ruth | NYY | AL |
| 1928 | Babe Ruth | NYY | ML |
| 1928 | Burleigh Grimes | PIT | NL |
| 1928 | Burleigh Grimes | PIT | ML |
| 1928 | Joe Sewell | CLE | AL |
| 1928 | Joe Sewell | CLE | ML |
| 1928 | Dazzy Vance | BRO | NL |
| 1928 | Dazzy Vance | BRO | ML |
| 1928 | Gabby Hartnett | CHC | NL |
| 1928 | Gabby Hartnett | CHC | ML |
| 1928 | Travis Jackson | NY1 | NL |
| 1928 | Pie Traynor | PIT | ML |
| 1928 | Pie Traynor | PIT | NL |
| 1928 | Jim Bottomley | STL | NL |
| 1928 | Mickey Cochrane | PHA | AL |
| 1928 | Al Simmons | PHA | AL |
| 1928 | Lefty Grove | PHA | AL |
| 1928 | Lefty Grove | PHA | ML |
| 1928 | Willie Kamm | CHW | AL |
| 1928 | Heinie Manush | SLA | ML |
| 1928 | Heinie Manush | SLA | AL |
| 1928 | Lou Gehrig | NYY | ML |
| 1928 | Lou Gehrig | NYY | AL |
| 1928 | Waite Hoyt | NYY | AL |
| 1928 | Tony Lazzeri | NYY | AL |
| 1928 | Lloyd Waner | PIT | NL |
| 1928 | Paul Waner | PIT | ML |
| 1928 | Paul Waner | PIT | NL |
| 1928 | Larry Benton | NY1 | ML |
| 1928 | Larry Benton | NY1 | NL |
| 1928 | General Crowder | SLA | AL |
| 1928 | Chick Hafey | STL | NL |
| 1928 | Ed Morris | BOS | AL |
| 1928 | Bill Sherdel | STL | NL |
| 1927 | Pete Alexander | STL | NL |
| 1927 | Babe Ruth | NYY | ML |
| 1927 | Babe Ruth | NYY | AL |
| 1927 | Frankie Frisch | STL | NL |
| 1927 | Frankie Frisch | STL | ML |
| 1927 | Joe Sewell | CLE | AL |
| 1927 | Gabby Hartnett | CHC | ML |
| 1927 | Gabby Hartnett | CHC | NL |
| 1927 | Travis Jackson | NY1 | ML |
| 1927 | Travis Jackson | NY1 | NL |
| 1927 | Pie Traynor | PIT | ML |
| 1927 | Pie Traynor | PIT | NL |
| 1927 | Ossie Bluege | WSN | AL |
| 1927 | Mickey Cochrane | PHA | AL |
| 1927 | Mickey Cochrane | PHA | ML |
| 1927 | Goose Goslin | WSN | AL |
| 1927 | Ted Lyons | CHW | AL |
| 1927 | Ted Lyons | CHW | ML |
| 1927 | Muddy Ruel | WSN | AL |
| 1927 | Al Simmons | PHA | AL |
| 1927 | Al Simmons | PHA | ML |
| 1927 | Lefty Grove | PHA | AL |
| 1927 | Lefty Grove | PHA | ML |
| 1927 | Jesse Petty | BRO | NL |
| 1927 | Hack Wilson | CHC | NL |
| 1927 | Lou Gehrig | NYY | ML |
| 1927 | Lou Gehrig | NYY | AL |
| 1927 | Jesse Haines | STL | ML |
| 1927 | Jesse Haines | STL | NL |
| 1927 | Waite Hoyt | NYY | AL |
| 1927 | Tony Lazzeri | NYY | AL |
| 1927 | Charlie Root | CHC | NL |
| 1927 | Charlie Root | CHC | ML |
| 1927 | Bill Terry | NY1 | NL |
| 1927 | Tommy Thomas | CHW | AL |
| 1927 | Lloyd Waner | PIT | NL |
| 1927 | Paul Waner | PIT | NL |
| 1927 | Paul Waner | PIT | ML |
| 1927 | Jimmie Wilson | PHI | NL |
| 1926 | Eddie Collins | CHW | AL |
| 1926 | Dave Bancroft | BSN | ML |
| 1926 | Dave Bancroft | BSN | NL |
| 1926 | Rogers Hornsby | STL | NL |
| 1926 | Rogers Hornsby | STL | ML |
| 1926 | Babe Ruth | NYY | ML |
| 1926 | Babe Ruth | NYY | AL |
| 1926 | Edd Roush | CIN | NL |
| 1926 | George Kelly | NY1 | NL |
| 1926 | Carl Mays | CIN | NL |
| 1926 | Joe Sewell | CLE | AL |
| 1926 | George Uhle | CLE | ML |
| 1926 | George Uhle | CLE | AL |
| 1926 | Herb Pennock | NYY | ML |
| 1926 | Herb Pennock | NYY | AL |
| 1926 | Pie Traynor | PIT | ML |
| 1926 | Pie Traynor | PIT | NL |
| 1926 | Kiki Cuyler | PIT | ML |
| 1926 | Kiki Cuyler | PIT | NL |
| 1926 | Ted Lyons | CHW | ML |
| 1926 | Ted Lyons | CHW | AL |
| 1926 | Muddy Ruel | WSN | AL |
| 1926 | Earl Smith | PIT | ML |
| 1926 | Earl Smith | PIT | NL |
| 1926 | George Burns | CLE | AL |
| 1926 | George Burns | CLE | ML |
| 1926 | Hal Carlson | PHI | NL |
| 1926 | Lefty Grove | PHA | AL |
| 1926 | Willie Kamm | CHW | AL |
| 1926 | Ray Kremer | PIT | NL |
| 1926 | Ray Kremer | PIT | ML |
| 1926 | Heinie Manush | DET | AL |
| 1926 | Johnny Mostil | CHW | AL |
| 1926 | Johnny Mostil | CHW | ML |
| 1926 | Jesse Petty | BRO | NL |
| 1926 | Hack Wilson | CHC | NL |
| 1925 | Eddie Collins | CHW | AL |
| 1925 | Walter Johnson | WSN | AL |
| 1925 | Walter Johnson | WSN | ML |
| 1925 | Pete Alexander | CHC | NL |
| 1925 | Zack Wheat | BRO | ML |
| 1925 | Zack Wheat | BRO | NL |
| 1925 | Rogers Hornsby | STL | NL |
| 1925 | Rogers Hornsby | STL | ML |
| 1925 | George Sisler | SLA | AL |
| 1925 | George Sisler | SLA | ML |
| 1925 | Max Carey | PIT | NL |
| 1925 | Stan Coveleski | WSN | AL |
| 1925 | Stan Coveleski | WSN | ML |
| 1925 | Eppa Rixey | CIN | NL |
| 1925 | Eppa Rixey | CIN | ML |
| 1925 | Harry Heilmann | DET | AL |
| 1925 | Joe Sewell | CLE | AL |
| 1925 | Dazzy Vance | BRO | NL |
| 1925 | Dazzy Vance | BRO | ML |
| 1925 | Gabby Hartnett | CHC | NL |
| 1925 | Herb Pennock | NYY | AL |
| 1925 | Pie Traynor | PIT | NL |
| 1925 | Pie Traynor | PIT | ML |
| 1925 | Ossie Bluege | WSN | AL |
| 1925 | Jim Bottomley | STL | NL |
| 1925 | Mickey Cochrane | PHA | ML |
| 1925 | Mickey Cochrane | PHA | AL |
| 1925 | Kiki Cuyler | PIT | ML |
| 1925 | Kiki Cuyler | PIT | NL |
| 1925 | Pete Donohue | CIN | NL |
| 1925 | Goose Goslin | WSN | AL |
| 1925 | Ted Lyons | CHW | AL |
| 1925 | Muddy Ruel | WSN | AL |
| 1925 | Muddy Ruel | WSN | ML |
| 1925 | Al Simmons | PHA | AL |
| 1925 | Al Simmons | PHA | ML |
| 1925 | Earl Smith | PIT | NL |
| 1925 | Glenn Wright | PIT | ML |
| 1925 | Glenn Wright | PIT | NL |
| 1924 | Ty Cobb | DET | AL |
| 1924 | Eddie Collins | CHW | AL |
| 1924 | Walter Johnson | WSN | ML |
| 1924 | Walter Johnson | WSN | AL |
| 1924 | Zack Wheat | BRO | ML |
| 1924 | Zack Wheat | BRO | NL |
| 1924 | Rogers Hornsby | STL | ML |
| 1924 | Rogers Hornsby | STL | NL |
| 1924 | Babe Ruth | NYY | AL |
| 1924 | Babe Ruth | NYY | ML |
| 1924 | Wilbur Cooper | PIT | NL |
| 1924 | Edd Roush | CIN | NL |
| 1924 | Edd Roush | CIN | ML |
| 1924 | Burleigh Grimes | BRO | NL |
| 1924 | Burleigh Grimes | BRO | ML |
| 1924 | Ross Youngs | NY1 | NL |
| 1924 | George Kelly | NY1 | NL |
| 1924 | George Kelly | NY1 | ML |
| 1924 | Joe Dugan | NYY | ML |
| 1924 | Joe Dugan | NYY | AL |
| 1924 | Joe Sewell | CLE | AL |
| 1924 | Dazzy Vance | BRO | NL |
| 1924 | Dazzy Vance | BRO | ML |
| 1924 | Johnny Bassler | DET | AL |
| 1924 | Johnny Bassler | DET | ML |
| 1924 | Gabby Hartnett | CHC | NL |
| 1924 | Travis Jackson | NY1 | NL |
| 1924 | Travis Jackson | NY1 | ML |
| 1924 | Charlie Jamieson | CLE | AL |
| 1924 | Joe Judge | WSN | AL |
| 1924 | Herb Pennock | NYY | AL |
| 1924 | Hollis Thurston | CHW | AL |
| 1924 | Pie Traynor | PIT | NL |
| 1923 | Eddie Collins | CHW | AL |
| 1923 | Eddie Collins | CHW | ML |
| 1923 | Walter Johnson | WSN | AL |
| 1923 | Walter Johnson | WSN | ML |
| 1923 | Tris Speaker | CLE | AL |
| 1923 | Tris Speaker | CLE | ML |
| 1923 | Pete Alexander | CHC | ML |
| 1923 | Pete Alexander | CHC | NL |
| 1923 | Zack Wheat | BRO | NL |
| 1923 | Dave Bancroft | NY1 | ML |
| 1923 | Dave Bancroft | NY1 | NL |
| 1923 | Rogers Hornsby | STL | NL |
| 1923 | Babe Ruth | NYY | ML |
| 1923 | Babe Ruth | NYY | AL |
| 1923 | Edd Roush | CIN | NL |
| 1923 | Edd Roush | CIN | ML |
| 1923 | Urban Shocker | SLA | AL |
| 1923 | Ross Youngs | NY1 | NL |
| 1923 | Frankie Frisch | NY1 | NL |
| 1923 | Frankie Frisch | NY1 | ML |
| 1923 | Joe Dugan | NYY | AL |
| 1923 | Howard Ehmke | BOS | AL |
| 1923 | Charlie Grimm | PIT | NL |
| 1923 | Charlie Grimm | PIT | ML |
| 1923 | Harry Heilmann | DET | AL |
| 1923 | Dolf Luque | CIN | NL |
| 1923 | Dolf Luque | CIN | ML |
| 1923 | Johnny Morrison | PIT | NL |
| 1923 | Bob O'Farrell | CHC | NL |
| 1923 | Bob O'Farrell | CHC | ML |
| 1923 | Cy Perkins | PHA | AL |
| 1923 | Wally Pipp | NYY | AL |
| 1923 | Joe Sewell | CLE | AL |
| 1923 | George Uhle | CLE | ML |
| 1923 | George Uhle | CLE | AL |
| 1923 | Dazzy Vance | BRO | NL |
| 1922 | Ty Cobb | DET | ML |
| 1922 | Ty Cobb | DET | AL |
| 1922 | Eddie Collins | CHW | AL |
| 1922 | Tris Speaker | CLE | ML |
| 1922 | Tris Speaker | CLE | AL |
| 1922 | Frank Snyder | NY1 | NL |
| 1922 | Cy Williams | PHI | AL |
| 1922 | Rogers Hornsby | STL | NL |
| 1922 | Rogers Hornsby | STL | ML |
| 1922 | George Sisler | SLA | AL |
| 1922 | George Sisler | SLA | ML |
| 1922 | Max Carey | PIT | ML |
| 1922 | Max Carey | PIT | NL |
| 1922 | Wilbur Cooper | PIT | NL |
| 1922 | Charlie Hollocher | CHC | ML |
| 1922 | Charlie Hollocher | CHC | NL |
| 1922 | Steve O'Neill | CLE | ML |
| 1922 | Steve O'Neill | CLE | AL |
| 1922 | Milt Stock | STL | NL |
| 1922 | Everett Scott | NYY | AL |
| 1922 | Urban Shocker | SLA | AL |
| 1922 | Ross Youngs | NY1 | NL |
| 1922 | Carson Bigbee | PIT | NL |
| 1922 | George Kelly | NY1 | NL |
| 1922 | Bullet Joe Bush | NYY | AL |
| 1922 | Bullet Joe Bush | NYY | ML |
| 1922 | Joe Dugan | BOS | AL |
| 1922 | Joe Dugan | BOS | ML |
| 1922 | Eppa Rixey | CIN | ML |
| 1922 | Eppa Rixey | CIN | NL |
| 1922 | Eddie Rommel | PHA | ML |
| 1922 | Eddie Rommel | PHA | AL |
| 1922 | Dutch Ruether | BRO | NL |
| 1921 | Ty Cobb | DET | AL |
| 1921 | Ty Cobb | DET | ML |
| 1921 | Eddie Collins | CHW | AL |
| 1921 | Tris Speaker | CLE | AL |
| 1921 | Tris Speaker | CLE | ML |
| 1921 | Larry Gardner | CLE | AL |
| 1921 | Dave Bancroft | NY1 | NL |
| 1921 | Dave Bancroft | NY1 | ML |
| 1921 | Rogers Hornsby | STL | ML |
| 1921 | Rogers Hornsby | STL | NL |
| 1921 | Babe Ruth | NYY | ML |
| 1921 | Babe Ruth | NYY | AL |
| 1921 | George Sisler | SLA | ML |
| 1921 | George Sisler | SLA | AL |
| 1921 | Wilbur Cooper | PIT | NL |
| 1921 | Edd Roush | CIN | NL |
| 1921 | Burleigh Grimes | BRO | ML |
| 1921 | Burleigh Grimes | BRO | NL |
| 1921 | Steve O'Neill | CLE | AL |
| 1921 | Steve O'Neill | CLE | ML |
| 1921 | Roger Peckinpaugh | NYY | AL |
| 1921 | Walter Schmidt | PIT | NL |
| 1921 | Urban Shocker | SLA | AL |
| 1921 | Ross Youngs | NY1 | NL |
| 1921 | Carson Bigbee | PIT | NL |
| 1921 | Red Faber | CHW | ML |
| 1921 | Red Faber | CHW | AL |
| 1921 | Frankie Frisch | NY1 | ML |
| 1921 | Frankie Frisch | NY1 | NL |
| 1921 | George Kelly | NY1 | NL |
| 1921 | Carl Mays | NYY | ML |
| 1921 | Carl Mays | NYY | AL |
| 1921 | Art Nehf | NY1 | NL |
| 1920 | Eddie Collins | CHW | AL |
| 1920 | Eddie Collins | CHW | ML |
| 1920 | Tris Speaker | CLE | ML |
| 1920 | Tris Speaker | CLE | AL |
| 1920 | Pete Alexander | CHC | ML |
| 1920 | Pete Alexander | CHC | NL |
| 1920 | Jake Daubert | CIN | NL |
| 1920 | Larry Gardner | CLE | AL |
| 1920 | Zack Wheat | BRO | NL |
| 1920 | Rabbit Maranville | BSN | NL |
| 1920 | Rabbit Maranville | BSN | ML |
| 1920 | Heinie Groh | CIN | ML |
| 1920 | Heinie Groh | CIN | NL |
| 1920 | Rogers Hornsby | STL | NL |
| 1920 | Babe Ruth | NYY | AL |
| 1920 | Babe Ruth | NYY | ML |
| 1920 | George Sisler | SLA | AL |
| 1920 | George Sisler | SLA | ML |
| 1920 | Wilbur Cooper | PIT | NL |
| 1920 | Edd Roush | CIN | ML |
| 1920 | Edd Roush | CIN | NL |
| 1920 | Burleigh Grimes | BRO | NL |
| 1920 | Burleigh Grimes | BRO | ML |
| 1920 | Steve O'Neill | CLE | AL |
| 1920 | Steve O'Neill | CLE | ML |
| 1920 | Jim Bagby | CLE | ML |
| 1920 | Jim Bagby | CLE | AL |
| 1920 | Stan Coveleski | CLE | AL |
| 1920 | Sam Rice | WSN | AL |
| 1920 | Walter Schmidt | PIT | NL |
| 1920 | Everett Scott | BOS | AL |
| 1920 | Urban Shocker | SLA | AL |
| 1920 | Ross Youngs | NY1 | NL |
| 1919 | Ty Cobb | DET | AL |
| 1919 | Ty Cobb | DET | ML |
| 1919 | Eddie Collins | CHW | AL |
| 1919 | Eddie Collins | CHW | ML |
| 1919 | Walter Johnson | WSN | AL |
| 1919 | Walter Johnson | WSN | ML |
| 1919 | Jake Daubert | CIN | NL |
| 1919 | Shoeless Joe Jackson | CHW | AL |
| 1919 | George Burns | NY1 | NL |
| 1919 | Ivey Wingo | CIN | NL |
| 1919 | Heinie Groh | CIN | NL |
| 1919 | Heinie Groh | CIN | ML |
| 1919 | Rogers Hornsby | STL | NL |
| 1919 | Babe Ruth | BOS | ML |
| 1919 | Babe Ruth | BOS | AL |
| 1919 | George Sisler | SLA | AL |
| 1919 | George Sisler | SLA | ML |
| 1919 | Eddie Cicotte | CHW | AL |
| 1919 | Edd Roush | CIN | ML |
| 1919 | Edd Roush | CIN | NL |
| 1919 | Buck Weaver | CHW | AL |
| 1919 | Steve O'Neill | CLE | AL |
| 1919 | Steve O'Neill | CLE | ML |
| 1919 | Hippo Vaughn | CHC | ML |
| 1919 | Hippo Vaughn | CHC | NL |
| 1919 | Jesse Barnes | NY1 | NL |
| 1919 | Hi Myers | BRO | NL |
| 1919 | Roger Peckinpaugh | NYY | AL |
| 1919 | Roger Peckinpaugh | NYY | ML |
| 1919 | Milt Stock | STL | NL |
| 1918 | Ty Cobb | DET | AL |
| 1918 | Ty Cobb | DET | ML |
| 1918 | Eddie Collins | CHW | AL |
| 1918 | Eddie Collins | CHW | ML |
| 1918 | Walter Johnson | WSN | ML |
| 1918 | Walter Johnson | WSN | AL |
| 1918 | Tris Speaker | CLE | ML |
| 1918 | Tris Speaker | CLE | AL |
| 1918 | Home Run Baker | NYY | AL |
| 1918 | Jake Daubert | BRO | NL |
| 1918 | Zack Wheat | BRO | NL |
| 1918 | George Burns | NY1 | NL |
| 1918 | Heinie Groh | CIN | ML |
| 1918 | Heinie Groh | CIN | NL |
| 1918 | Babe Ruth | BOS | ML |
| 1918 | Babe Ruth | BOS | AL |
| 1918 | George Sisler | SLA | ML |
| 1918 | George Sisler | SLA | AL |
| 1918 | Ray Chapman | CLE | AL |
| 1918 | Bill Killefer | CHC | NL |
| 1918 | Bill Killefer | CHC | ML |
| 1918 | Edd Roush | CIN | NL |
| 1918 | Edd Roush | CIN | ML |
| 1918 | George Cutshaw | PIT | NL |
| 1918 | Burleigh Grimes | BRO | NL |
| 1918 | Charlie Hollocher | CHC | ML |
| 1918 | Charlie Hollocher | CHC | NL |
| 1918 | Harry Hooper | BOS | AL |
| 1918 | Steve O'Neill | CLE | AL |
| 1918 | Hippo Vaughn | CHC | ML |
| 1918 | Hippo Vaughn | CHC | NL |
| 1917 | Hal Chase | CIN | NL |
| 1917 | Ty Cobb | DET | AL |
| 1917 | Ty Cobb | DET | ML |
| 1917 | Eddie Collins | CHW | AL |
| 1917 | Eddie Collins | CHW | ML |
| 1917 | Walter Johnson | WSN | AL |
| 1917 | Walter Johnson | WSN | ML |
| 1917 | Tris Speaker | CLE | AL |
| 1917 | Tris Speaker | CLE | ML |
| 1917 | Pete Alexander | PHI | NL |
| 1917 | Pete Alexander | PHI | ML |
| 1917 | Heinie Zimmerman | NY1 | ML |
| 1917 | Heinie Zimmerman | NY1 | NL |
| 1917 | George Burns | NY1 | NL |
| 1917 | Rabbit Maranville | BSN | NL |
| 1917 | Ray Schalk | CHW | AL |
| 1917 | Buck Herzog | NY1 | NL |
| 1917 | George Sisler | SLA | AL |
| 1917 | George Sisler | SLA | ML |
| 1917 | Max Carey | PIT | NL |
| 1917 | Ray Chapman | CLE | AL |
| 1917 | Ray Chapman | CLE | ML |
| 1917 | Eddie Cicotte | CHW | AL |
| 1917 | Wilbur Cooper | PIT | NL |
| 1917 | Happy Felsch | CHW | AL |
| 1917 | Bill Killefer | PHI | ML |
| 1917 | Bill Killefer | PHI | NL |
| 1917 | Edd Roush | CIN | NL |
| 1917 | Edd Roush | CIN | ML |
| 1917 | Buck Weaver | CHW | AL |
| 1916 | Ty Cobb | DET | ML |
| 1916 | Ty Cobb | DET | AL |
| 1916 | Donie Bush | DET | AL |
| 1916 | Eddie Collins | CHW | AL |
| 1916 | Eddie Collins | CHW | ML |
| 1916 | Walter Johnson | WSN | AL |
| 1916 | Walter Johnson | WSN | ML |
| 1916 | Tris Speaker | CLE | ML |
| 1916 | Tris Speaker | CLE | AL |
| 1916 | Pete Alexander | PHI | ML |
| 1916 | Pete Alexander | PHI | NL |
| 1916 | Jake Daubert | BRO | NL |
| 1916 | Jake Daubert | BRO | ML |
| 1916 | Shoeless Joe Jackson | CHW | AL |
| 1916 | Shoeless Joe Jackson | CHW | ML |
| 1916 | Larry Gardner | BOS | ML |
| 1916 | Larry Gardner | BOS | AL |
| 1916 | Zack Wheat | BRO | NL |
| 1916 | Rabbit Maranville | BSN | ML |
| 1916 | Rabbit Maranville | BSN | NL |
| 1916 | Ray Schalk | CHW | AL |
| 1916 | Ray Schalk | CHW | ML |
| 1916 | Al Mamaux | PIT | NL |
| 1916 | Cy Williams | CHC | NL |
| 1916 | Hank Gowdy | BSN | NL |
| 1916 | Buck Herzog | CIN | NL |
| 1916 | Rogers Hornsby | STL | NL |
| 1916 | Dave Robertson | NY1 | NL |
| 1916 | Babe Ruth | BOS | AL |
| 1916 | George Sisler | SLA | AL |
| 1915 | Ty Cobb | DET | AL |
| 1915 | Ty Cobb | DET | ML |
| 1915 | Sam Crawford | DET | AL |
| 1915 | Sam Crawford | DET | ML |
| 1915 | Donie Bush | DET | AL |
| 1915 | Eddie Collins | CHW | AL |
| 1915 | Eddie Collins | CHW | ML |
| 1915 | Walter Johnson | WSN | ML |
| 1915 | Walter Johnson | WSN | AL |
| 1915 | Tris Speaker | BOS | AL |
| 1915 | Tris Speaker | BOS | ML |
| 1915 | Pete Alexander | PHI | NL |
| 1915 | Pete Alexander | PHI | ML |
| 1915 | Larry Doyle | NY1 | NL |
| 1915 | Stuffy McInnis | PHA | AL |
| 1915 | Stuffy McInnis | PHA | ML |
| 1915 | Gavvy Cravath | PHI | NL |
| 1915 | Zack Wheat | BRO | NL |
| 1915 | Ray Schalk | CHW | AL |
| 1915 | Dave Bancroft | PHI | NL |
| 1915 | Dave Bancroft | PHI | ML |
| 1915 | Heinie Groh | CIN | NL |
| 1915 | Heinie Groh | CIN | ML |
| 1915 | Fritz Maisel | NYY | AL |
| 1915 | Al Mamaux | PIT | NL |
| 1915 | Vic Saier | CHC | NL |
| 1915 | Jim Scott | CHW | AL |
| 1915 | Frank Snyder | STL | ML |
| 1915 | Frank Snyder | STL | NL |
| 1915 | Cy Williams | CHC | NL |
| 1914 | Christy Mathewson | NY1 | NL |
| 1914 | Christy Mathewson | NY1 | ML |
| 1914 | Ty Cobb | DET | AL |
| 1914 | Ty Cobb | DET | ML |
| 1914 | Johnny Evers | BSN | NL |
| 1914 | Eddie Collins | PHA | AL |
| 1914 | Eddie Collins | PHA | ML |
| 1914 | Walter Johnson | WSN | ML |
| 1914 | Walter Johnson | WSN | AL |
| 1914 | Eddie Plank | PHA | AL |
| 1914 | Tris Speaker | BOS | ML |
| 1914 | Tris Speaker | BOS | AL |
| 1914 | Jimmy Archer | CHC | ML |
| 1914 | Jimmy Archer | CHC | NL |
| 1914 | Sherry Magee | PHI | NL |
| 1914 | Pete Alexander | PHI | ML |
| 1914 | Pete Alexander | PHI | NL |
| 1914 | Home Run Baker | PHA | AL |
| 1914 | Home Run Baker | PHA | ML |
| 1914 | Jake Daubert | BRO | NL |
| 1914 | Jake Daubert | BRO | ML |
| 1914 | Shoeless Joe Jackson | CLE | ML |
| 1914 | Shoeless Joe Jackson | CLE | AL |
| 1914 | Hans Lobert | PHI | NL |
| 1914 | Stuffy McInnis | PHA | AL |
| 1914 | Jack Barry | PHA | AL |
| 1914 | Wally Schang | PHA | ML |
| 1914 | Wally Schang | PHA | AL |
| 1914 | Zack Wheat | BRO | NL |
| 1914 | George Burns | NY1 | NL |
| 1914 | Bill James | BSN | NL |
| 1914 | Dutch Leonard | BOS | AL |
| 1914 | Rabbit Maranville | BSN | NL |
| 1914 | Rabbit Maranville | BSN | ML |
| 1914 | Ray Schalk | CHW | AL |
| 1914 | Ivey Wingo | STL | NL |
| 1913 | Christy Mathewson | NY1 | ML |
| 1913 | Christy Mathewson | NY1 | NL |
| 1913 | Ty Cobb | DET | ML |
| 1913 | Ty Cobb | DET | AL |
| 1913 | Honus Wagner | PIT | ML |
| 1913 | Honus Wagner | PIT | NL |
| 1913 | Eddie Collins | PHA | AL |
| 1913 | Eddie Collins | PHA | ML |
| 1913 | Walter Johnson | WSN | AL |
| 1913 | Walter Johnson | WSN | ML |
| 1913 | Tommy Leach | CHC | NL |
| 1913 | Tris Speaker | BOS | AL |
| 1913 | Tris Speaker | BOS | ML |
| 1913 | Jimmy Archer | CHC | ML |
| 1913 | Jimmy Archer | CHC | NL |
| 1913 | Pete Alexander | PHI | NL |
| 1913 | Home Run Baker | PHA | AL |
| 1913 | Home Run Baker | PHA | ML |
| 1913 | Jake Daubert | BRO | ML |
| 1913 | Jake Daubert | BRO | NL |
| 1913 | Shoeless Joe Jackson | CLE | AL |
| 1913 | Shoeless Joe Jackson | CLE | ML |
| 1913 | Stuffy McInnis | PHA | AL |
| 1913 | Heinie Zimmerman | CHC | NL |
| 1913 | Jack Barry | PHA | AL |
| 1913 | Gavvy Cravath | PHI | NL |
| 1913 | Cy Falkenberg | CLE | AL |
| 1913 | Wally Schang | PHA | AL |
| 1913 | Jim Viox | PIT | NL |
| 1913 | Zack Wheat | BRO | NL |
| 1912 | Christy Mathewson | NY1 | NL |
| 1912 | Ty Cobb | DET | AL |
| 1912 | Ty Cobb | DET | ML |
| 1912 | Johnny Evers | CHC | ML |
| 1912 | Johnny Evers | CHC | NL |
| 1912 | Nap Rucker | BRO | ML |
| 1912 | Nap Rucker | BRO | NL |
| 1912 | Honus Wagner | PIT | NL |
| 1912 | Honus Wagner | PIT | ML |
| 1912 | Eddie Collins | PHA | AL |
| 1912 | Walter Johnson | WSN | AL |
| 1912 | Walter Johnson | WSN | ML |
| 1912 | Eddie Plank | PHA | AL |
| 1912 | Tris Speaker | BOS | ML |
| 1912 | Tris Speaker | BOS | AL |
| 1912 | Smoky Joe Wood | BOS | ML |
| 1912 | Smoky Joe Wood | BOS | AL |
| 1912 | Jimmy Archer | CHC | NL |
| 1912 | Jimmy Archer | CHC | ML |
| 1912 | Sherry Magee | PHI | NL |
| 1912 | Jake Daubert | BRO | ML |
| 1912 | Jake Daubert | BRO | NL |
| 1912 | Shoeless Joe Jackson | CLE | AL |
| 1912 | Shoeless Joe Jackson | CLE | ML |
| 1912 | Jack Meyers | NY1 | ML |
| 1912 | Jack Meyers | NY1 | NL |
| 1912 | Oscar Stanage | DET | AL |
| 1912 | Eddie Ainsmith | WSN | AL |
| 1912 | Larry Gardner | BOS | AL |
| 1912 | Stuffy McInnis | PHA | AL |
| 1912 | Dode Paskert | PHI | NL |
| 1912 | Jeff Tesreau | NY1 | NL |
| 1912 | Heinie Wagner | BOS | AL |
| 1912 | Owen Wilson | PIT | NL |
| 1912 | Heinie Zimmerman | CHC | ML |
| 1912 | Heinie Zimmerman | CHC | NL |
| 1911 | Christy Mathewson | NY1 | ML |
| 1911 | Christy Mathewson | NY1 | NL |
| 1911 | Roger Bresnahan | STL | ML |
| 1911 | Roger Bresnahan | STL | NL |
| 1911 | Hal Chase | NYY | AL |
| 1911 | Hal Chase | NYY | ML |
| 1911 | Fred Clarke | PIT | ML |
| 1911 | Fred Clarke | PIT | NL |
| 1911 | Ty Cobb | DET | AL |
| 1911 | Ty Cobb | DET | ML |
| 1911 | Sam Crawford | DET | AL |
| 1911 | Mike Donlin | BSN | NL |
| 1911 | Nap Rucker | BRO | ML |
| 1911 | Nap Rucker | BRO | NL |
| 1911 | Frank Schulte | CHC | NL |
| 1911 | Honus Wagner | PIT | ML |
| 1911 | Honus Wagner | PIT | NL |
| 1911 | Ed Walsh | CHW | ML |
| 1911 | Ed Walsh | CHW | AL |
| 1911 | Donie Bush | DET | AL |
| 1911 | Bill Carrigan | BOS | AL |
| 1911 | Eddie Collins | PHA | AL |
| 1911 | Eddie Collins | PHA | ML |
| 1911 | Walter Johnson | WSN | AL |
| 1911 | Walter Johnson | WSN | ML |
| 1911 | Jimmy Archer | CHC | NL |
| 1911 | Charles Bender | PHA | AL |
| 1911 | Jack Coombs | PHA | AL |
| 1911 | Ira Thomas | PHA | ML |
| 1911 | Ira Thomas | PHA | AL |
| 1911 | Pete Alexander | PHI | NL |
| 1911 | Pete Alexander | PHI | ML |
| 1911 | Home Run Baker | PHA | ML |
| 1911 | Home Run Baker | PHA | AL |
| 1911 | Jake Daubert | BRO | NL |
| 1911 | Red Dooin | PHI | ML |
| 1911 | Red Dooin | PHI | NL |
| 1911 | Larry Doyle | NY1 | NL |
| 1911 | Vean Gregg | CLE | AL |
| 1911 | Vean Gregg | CLE | ML |
| 1911 | Shoeless Joe Jackson | CLE | AL |
| 1911 | Shoeless Joe Jackson | CLE | ML |
| 1911 | Hans Lobert | PHI | NL |
| 1911 | Rube Marquard | NY1 | NL |
| 1911 | Jack Meyers | NY1 | NL |
| 1911 | Jack Meyers | NY1 | ML |
| 1911 | Oscar Stanage | DET | AL |
| 1910 | Nap Lajoie | CLE | AL |
| 1910 | Nap Lajoie | CLE | ML |
| 1910 | Christy Mathewson | NY1 | NL |
| 1910 | Christy Mathewson | NY1 | ML |
| 1910 | Hal Chase | NYY | ML |
| 1910 | Hal Chase | NYY | AL |
| 1910 | Ty Cobb | DET | ML |
| 1910 | Ty Cobb | DET | AL |
| 1910 | Art Devlin | NY1 | ML |
| 1910 | Art Devlin | NY1 | NL |
| 1910 | Johnny Evers | CHC | NL |
| 1910 | Harry Lord | BOS | AL |
| 1910 | Nap Rucker | BRO | NL |
| 1910 | Frank Schulte | CHC | NL |
| 1910 | George Stone | SLA | AL |
| 1910 | Honus Wagner | PIT | NL |
| 1910 | Honus Wagner | PIT | ML |
| 1910 | Bobby Wallace | SLA | AL |
| 1910 | Ed Walsh | CHW | AL |
| 1910 | Ed Walsh | CHW | ML |
| 1910 | Frank Chance | CHC | NL |
| 1910 | George Gibson | PIT | ML |
| 1910 | George Gibson | PIT | NL |
| 1910 | Walter Johnson | WSN | ML |
| 1910 | Tommy Leach | PIT | NL |
| 1910 | Tris Speaker | BOS | ML |
| 1910 | Tris Speaker | BOS | AL |
| 1910 | Jimmy Archer | CHC | ML |
| 1910 | Jimmy Archer | CHC | NL |
| 1910 | Charles Bender | PHA | ML |
| 1910 | Charles Bender | PHA | AL |
| 1910 | King Cole | CHC | NL |
| 1910 | Jack Coombs | PHA | AL |
| 1910 | Jack Coombs | PHA | ML |
| 1910 | Sherry Magee | PHI | ML |
| 1910 | Sherry Magee | PHI | NL |
| 1910 | Ed Sweeney | NYY | AL |
| 1910 | Ira Thomas | PHA | AL |
| 1909 | Christy Mathewson | NY1 | ML |
| 1909 | Christy Mathewson | NY1 | NL |
| 1909 | Roger Bresnahan | STL | NL |
| 1909 | Mordecai Brown | CHC | NL |
| 1909 | Mordecai Brown | CHC | ML |
| 1909 | Hal Chase | NYY | ML |
| 1909 | Hal Chase | NYY | AL |
| 1909 | Fred Clarke | PIT | NL |
| 1909 | Fred Clarke | PIT | ML |
| 1909 | Ty Cobb | DET | AL |
| 1909 | Ty Cobb | DET | ML |
| 1909 | Sam Crawford | DET | AL |
| 1909 | Art Devlin | NY1 | NL |
| 1909 | Johnny Evers | CHC | NL |
| 1909 | Johnny Kling | - | ML |
| 1909 | Johnny Kling | - | NL |
| 1909 | Harry Lord | BOS | AL |
| 1909 | Harry Lord | BOS | ML |
| 1909 | Ed Reulbach | CHC | NL |
| 1909 | Billy Sullivan | CHW | AL |
| 1909 | Honus Wagner | PIT | NL |
| 1909 | Honus Wagner | PIT | ML |
| 1909 | Ed Walsh | CHW | AL |
| 1909 | Ed Walsh | CHW | ML |
| 1909 | Babe Adams | PIT | NL |
| 1909 | Babe Adams | PIT | ML |
| 1909 | Donie Bush | DET | AL |
| 1909 | Howie Camnitz | PIT | NL |
| 1909 | Bill Carrigan | BOS | AL |
| 1909 | Bill Carrigan | BOS | ML |
| 1909 | Frank Chance | CHC | NL |
| 1909 | Eddie Collins | PHA | ML |
| 1909 | Eddie Collins | PHA | AL |
| 1909 | George Gibson | PIT | NL |
| 1909 | George Gibson | PIT | ML |
| 1909 | Solly Hofman | CHC | NL |
| 1909 | Walter Johnson | WSN | ML |
| 1909 | Walter Johnson | WSN | AL |
| 1909 | Tommy Leach | PIT | NL |
| 1909 | George Mullin | DET | AL |
| 1909 | Eddie Plank | PHA | AL |
| 1909 | Eddie Plank | PHA | ML |
| 1909 | Tris Speaker | BOS | ML |
| 1909 | Tris Speaker | BOS | AL |
| 1909 | Gabby Street | WSN | AL |
| 1909 | Smoky Joe Wood | BOS | AL |
| 1908 | Nap Lajoie | CLE | AL |
| 1908 | Nap Lajoie | CLE | ML |
| 1908 | Cy Young | BOS | ML |
| 1908 | Cy Young | BOS | AL |
| 1908 | Christy Mathewson | NY1 | ML |
| 1908 | Christy Mathewson | NY1 | NL |
| 1908 | Rube Waddell | SLA | AL |
| 1908 | Roger Bresnahan | NY1 | ML |
| 1908 | Roger Bresnahan | NY1 | NL |
| 1908 | Mordecai Brown | CHC | NL |
| 1908 | Mordecai Brown | CHC | ML |
| 1908 | Hal Chase | NYY | AL |
| 1908 | Hal Chase | NYY | ML |
| 1908 | Fred Clarke | PIT | ML |
| 1908 | Fred Clarke | PIT | NL |
| 1908 | Ty Cobb | DET | AL |
| 1908 | Ty Cobb | DET | ML |
| 1908 | Sam Crawford | DET | AL |
| 1908 | Lou Criger | BOS | AL |
| 1908 | Art Devlin | NY1 | ML |
| 1908 | Art Devlin | NY1 | NL |
| 1908 | Mike Donlin | NY1 | NL |
| 1908 | Mike Donlin | NY1 | ML |
| 1908 | Bill Donovan | DET | AL |
| 1908 | Johnny Evers | CHC | NL |
| 1908 | Addie Joss | CLE | AL |
| 1908 | Johnny Kling | CHC | ML |
| 1908 | Johnny Kling | CHC | NL |
| 1908 | Harry Lord | BOS | AL |
| 1908 | Ed Reulbach | CHC | NL |
| 1908 | Nap Rucker | BRO | ML |
| 1908 | Nap Rucker | BRO | NL |
| 1908 | Frank Schulte | CHC | NL |
| 1908 | George Stone | SLA | AL |
| 1908 | Billy Sullivan | CHW | AL |
| 1908 | Fred Tenney | NY1 | NL |
| 1908 | Honus Wagner | PIT | ML |
| 1908 | Honus Wagner | PIT | NL |
| 1908 | Bobby Wallace | SLA | AL |
| 1908 | Ed Walsh | CHW | ML |
| 1908 | Ed Walsh | CHW | AL |
| 1908 | Vic Willis | PIT | NL |